THIS VAST ENTERPRISE/LEWIS AND CLARK REVISITED/ CRAIG FEHRMAN

It is difficult task to author a living history of events that took place in 1804. It is obvious that there is no-one who was present to interview. That is the challenge faced by author and historian Craig Fehrman in his new book THIS VAST ENTERPRISE, A New History of Lewis and Clark. Thus the book which attempts to fill in the blanks of past research on this enterprise uses much oral history, sometimes based on interviews with the recollections and traditions of living Native Americans, passed on to them through the fog generations.

Fehrman narrates a compelling story of Thomas Jefferson’s Corps of Discovery bringing new insight into those other than Meriwether Lewis and William Clark themselves. We learn about York an African American slave owned by William Clark initially brought along to serve Clark’s personal needs. York’s impact on the success of the great adventure was legion. John Ordway a working class soldier on many occasions saved the day through his heroics.The story of Sacajawea with a new born on her back is told in great depth with deep insight into the Blackfoot culture. This part of the narrative is superior in its insight of her character.

This is of course a story of Manifest Destiny . However, the Thomas Jefferson philosophy adds a new dimension which he called ” our right of preemption.”” When an imperial nation came across ” new” land it could claim the territory through rituals of discovery-planting flags-making maps and through occupation.” Little did the Blackfoot, Sioux, Mandam, Nez Perce and others understand the meaning of “preemption.” By the end of the century their decendents would know.

This is a tale of courage, suspense and mystery and speculation upon the unknown circumstances of heros and villians. The mission to find a water communication to the Pacific Ocean was a failure only because Lewis and Clark with the help of Sacagawea and Blackfoot Tribe’s horses proved that after the Missouri River ended, the final leg was an arduous and treacherous mountain journey to the Columbia River.

The book is great storytelling and I think necessarily wanders between non-fiction and a historical novel. An important read for those who wish to immerse themselves in this important part of American History. It also gives further insight into Jefferson’s thinking of America’s future as an agricultural enterprise supported by slavery from sea to sea. Ironically, part of the expeditions lasting legacy may be the children that both Lewis and Clark fathered whose ancestors now live to tell the tale.

EMPIRE OF THE SUMMER MOON

S.C. Gwynne’s Empire of the Summer Moon is a work of non-fiction deserving of its finalist status for a  2011 Pulitzer.  What is so haunting about this book is an un-avoidable love-hate relationship with the Comanche’s of West Texas and the High Plains in the period  1830-1875. 

You will come to respect the greatest mounted warriors  that ever lived in North America. Witness the absolute freedom of Comanche life on the high plains, totally in harmony with the soil, water, wind, buffalo, and of course the horse.   Then there is the depravity, ruthless killing of rival tribes and  later the slaughter of white settlers.  Men, women and children hacked to death or kidnapped, raped and mutilated without remorse. 

Within this barbaric tale evolves the portrait of Cynthia Ann Parker, captured at 9 years of age after watching her family slaughtered  by a Comanche raiding party.  Parker  embraces the Indian culture, marries a head man and bears two sons. Later, found by the U.S. Army among a wandering Comanche tribe, she is returned to ” civilization”  and put on display almost as a freak show.  Members of the Parker family hand her off from one to another as she tried desperately to return to Indian life and her sons.  She died broken-hearted never knowing what happened to her husband and two sons.  Son Quanah who saw his mother taken away by soldiers at age twelve grows to become the most brutal Comanche  worrier of his time.

Gwynne’s research  is worthy of the book’s sub-title. Quanah Parker the Rise and Fall of the Comanches, the Most Powerful Indian Tribe in American History.  Gwynne’s vivid detail and attention to the historical record forces the reader to try to reconcile the many faces of the Comanche, mounted nomads of the Great Plains.  It is all here, Spanish Colonialism in West Texas, The Civil War,  Manifest Destiny, the destruction of the great buffalo herds and of course the true story of Cynthia Ann Parker and her son Quanah.  Quanah from wild murdering Comanche orhpan to dinner with President Teddy Roosevelt.

Empire of the Summer Moon places this incredible tale in proper historical perspective. Don’t look for a historical novel here, this is a well researched narrative and wonderful story.